Markdown source

Transcript: Running a Chess YouTube Channel entirely by AI — Stephan Steinfurt, TNG

Source Video

Local Cache

Transcript

Hello everyone. Hello everyone. Um yeah, Swyx wrote a blog post and Um yeah, Swyx wrote a blog post and Um yeah, Swyx wrote a blog post and said, "Okay, don't write boring titles." said, "Okay, don't write boring titles." said, "Okay, don't write boring titles." So, I changed my title again actually So, I changed my title again actually So, I changed my title again actually and said, "Okay, we are working on the and said, "Okay, we are working on the and said, "Okay, we are working on the holy grail of chess programming." And if holy grail of chess programming." And if holy grail of chess programming." And if you knew me, I mean, I'm usually not the you knew me, I mean, I'm usually not the you knew me, I mean, I'm usually not the kind of guy who oversells stuff. So, kind of guy who oversells stuff. So, kind of guy who oversells stuff. So, it's actually a quote from someone else it's actually a quote from someone else it's actually a quote from someone else about this because like roughly a week about this because like roughly a week about this because like roughly a week ago there was an article on on one of ago there was an article on on one of ago there was an article on on one of the biggest newspapers in Germany which the biggest newspapers in Germany which the biggest newspapers in Germany which was um was um was um discussed a couple of approaches to um discussed a couple of approaches to um discussed a couple of approaches to um yeah, new approaches to doing um yeah, yeah, new approaches to doing um yeah, yeah, new approaches to doing um yeah, combining AI with chess. And yeah, they combining AI with chess. And yeah, they combining AI with chess. And yeah, they had said um it could easily take another had said um it could easily take another had said um it could easily take another 5 years until AI explains chess as well 5 years until AI explains chess as well 5 years until AI explains chess as well as a human trainer. Wilhelm Weber calls as a human trainer. Wilhelm Weber calls as a human trainer. Wilhelm Weber calls it the holy grail of chess program and it the holy grail of chess program and it the holy grail of chess program and work is already underway in Munich and work is already underway in Munich and work is already underway in Munich and that's basically where we are from, that's basically where we are from, that's basically where we are from, right? right? right? And we showed them a couple of videos um And we showed them a couple of videos um And we showed them a couple of videos um that my bosses mentioned and myself. that my bosses mentioned and myself. that my bosses mentioned and myself. And yeah, they were completely created And yeah, they were completely created And yeah, they were completely created by our AI engine. I want to quickly tell by our AI engine. I want to quickly tell by our AI engine. I want to quickly tell you a little bit how that's uh working. you a little bit how that's uh working. you a little bit how that's uh working. So, maybe um So, maybe um So, maybe um don't want to only show it to the don't want to only show it to the don't want to only show it to the newspaper but also show it to you. newspaper but also show it to you. newspaper but also show it to you. There's a 2-minute video of what the There's a 2-minute video of what the There's a 2-minute video of what the outcome is. outcome is. outcome is. So, I'm going to start it now. So, I'm going to start it now. So, I'm going to start it now. Hello chess fans. Hello chess fans. Hello chess fans. In this position, black's queen is In this position, black's queen is In this position, black's queen is currently under fire from the white rook currently under fire from the white rook currently under fire from the white rook on the H file. on the H file. on the H file. Trying to find safety, black slides the Trying to find safety, black slides the Trying to find safety, black slides the queen over to G4. queen over to G4. queen over to G4. This is a crushing blunder. This is a crushing blunder. This is a crushing blunder. It looks like a completely safe square, It looks like a completely safe square, It looks like a completely safe square, but moving off the H file allows white but moving off the H file allows white but moving off the H file allows white to unleash a spectacular, mind-bending to unleash a spectacular, mind-bending to unleash a spectacular, mind-bending sacrifice. sacrifice. sacrifice. White plays rook takes H5. White plays rook takes H5. White plays rook takes H5. White is offering up a full exchange, White is offering up a full exchange, White is offering up a full exchange, but this is a masterful trap built on but this is a masterful trap built on but this is a masterful trap built on incredible knight geometry. incredible knight geometry. incredible knight geometry. Let's look at what happens if black Let's look at what happens if black Let's look at what happens if black takes the bait. takes the bait. takes the bait. First, if black simply recaptures with First, if black simply recaptures with First, if black simply recaptures with the G pawn taking on H5, the G pawn taking on H5, the G pawn taking on H5, white springs the trap. white springs the trap. white springs the trap. The knight jumps into the action with The knight jumps into the action with The knight jumps into the action with knight to F6 with check. knight to F6 with check. knight to F6 with check. Look at this beautiful octopus knight on Look at this beautiful octopus knight on Look at this beautiful octopus knight on F6. F6. F6. It hits the king on G8 while It hits the king on G8 while It hits the king on G8 while simultaneously skewering that newly simultaneously skewering that newly simultaneously skewering that newly placed queen on G4. placed queen on G4. placed queen on G4. A lethal fork. A lethal fork. A lethal fork. The king is forced to step aside to F8, The king is forced to step aside to F8, The king is forced to step aside to F8, and the knight simply scoops up the and the knight simply scoops up the and the knight simply scoops up the queen on G4. queen on G4. queen on G4. But wait, let's back up. But wait, let's back up. But wait, let's back up. What if black tries to be clever and What if black tries to be clever and What if black tries to be clever and avoids the pawn capture? avoids the pawn capture? avoids the pawn capture? Black could capture the rook with the Black could capture the rook with the Black could capture the rook with the queen playing queen takes H5. queen playing queen takes H5. queen playing queen takes H5. But it is the exact same trap. The queen But it is the exact same trap. The queen But it is the exact same trap. The queen is attracted right into the danger zone. is attracted right into the danger zone. is attracted right into the danger zone. By pulling the queen to H5, white set up By pulling the queen to H5, white set up By pulling the queen to H5, white set up the exact same trick and plays knight to the exact same trick and plays knight to the exact same trick and plays knight to F6 check anyway. F6 check anyway. F6 check anyway. Once again, the king is attacked and the Once again, the king is attacked and the Once again, the king is attacked and the knight reaches across the board to knight reaches across the board to knight reaches across the board to attack the queen on H5. attack the queen on H5. attack the queen on H5. No matter how black captures the No matter how black captures the No matter how black captures the sacrificed rook, the queen gets forked sacrificed rook, the queen gets forked sacrificed rook, the queen gets forked because this knight magically controls because this knight magically controls because this knight magically controls both G4 and H5. both G4 and H5. both G4 and H5. The king must step aside to F8, and the The king must step aside to F8, and the The king must step aside to F8, and the knight captures the queen on H5. knight captures the queen on H5. knight captures the queen on H5. This is a gorgeous double-duty fork This is a gorgeous double-duty fork This is a gorgeous double-duty fork demonstrating the terrifying hidden demonstrating the terrifying hidden demonstrating the terrifying hidden power of the knight. power of the knight. power of the knight. Always watch out for these tricky Always watch out for these tricky Always watch out for these tricky jumping pieces when your king is jumping pieces when your king is jumping pieces when your king is exposed. exposed. exposed. So actually when I prepared the talk So actually when I prepared the talk So actually when I prepared the talk yesterday, I um I wanted to show a yesterday, I um I wanted to show a yesterday, I um I wanted to show a different video, but um yeah, we are um different video, but um yeah, we are um different video, but um yeah, we are um automatically creating these videos automatically creating these videos automatically creating these videos every every night and then uploading every every night and then uploading every every night and then uploading them to YouTube. And when I this morning them to YouTube. And when I this morning them to YouTube. And when I this morning had a quick look if there's anything had a quick look if there's anything had a quick look if there's anything embarrassing there which I could should embarrassing there which I could should embarrassing there which I could should hide hide from all of you. I thought, hide hide from all of you. I thought, hide hide from all of you. I thought, okay, actually there's this video and okay, actually there's this video and okay, actually there's this video and it's actually even better than the other it's actually even better than the other it's actually even better than the other one. So, might go for that one. one. So, might go for that one. one. So, might go for that one. And yeah, as I said, it's automatically And yeah, as I said, it's automatically And yeah, as I said, it's automatically created. created. created. We We We basically download basically download basically download chess games from lichess every night and chess games from lichess every night and chess games from lichess every night and analyze them in the background and then analyze them in the background and then analyze them in the background and then let our agent run and analyze it in more let our agent run and analyze it in more let our agent run and analyze it in more depth. From that analysis we then create depth. From that analysis we then create depth. From that analysis we then create some special format with from which we some special format with from which we some special format with from which we can later on then create a video. And can later on then create a video. And can later on then create a video. And yeah, the video in the end shows yeah, the video in the end shows yeah, the video in the end shows variations being explained. It shows variations being explained. It shows variations being explained. It shows brilliant moves, blunders, and yeah, and brilliant moves, blunders, and yeah, and brilliant moves, blunders, and yeah, and it's all automated. it's all automated. it's all automated. And yeah, so And yeah, so And yeah, so how does it work? So, maybe backing up a how does it work? So, maybe backing up a how does it work? So, maybe backing up a little bit, what's the general problem? little bit, what's the general problem? little bit, what's the general problem? The problem is we've had really good The problem is we've had really good The problem is we've had really good chess engines for multiple yeah, decades chess engines for multiple yeah, decades chess engines for multiple yeah, decades actually. And but they can't really actually. And but they can't really actually. And but they can't really explain chess well. On the other hand, explain chess well. On the other hand, explain chess well. On the other hand, we have now LLMs, they can well, say um we have now LLMs, they can well, say um we have now LLMs, they can well, say um have words and describe things, but they have words and describe things, but they have words and describe things, but they can't play chess well. So, we have to can't play chess well. So, we have to can't play chess well. So, we have to somehow combine them. That's the main somehow combine them. That's the main somehow combine them. That's the main challenge. challenge. challenge. And yeah, we have now have built an And yeah, we have now have built an And yeah, we have now have built an agent which has a lot of tools which is agent which has a lot of tools which is agent which has a lot of tools which is basically the main basically the main basically the main yeah, important ingredient here. But yeah, important ingredient here. But yeah, important ingredient here. But what is also important is the LLM which what is also important is the LLM which what is also important is the LLM which we're using under the hood. So, Gemini 3 we're using under the hood. So, Gemini 3 we're using under the hood. So, Gemini 3 but 1 Pro which recently came out is but 1 Pro which recently came out is but 1 Pro which recently came out is actually like the actually like the actually like the best model I seen so far on on chess. best model I seen so far on on chess. best model I seen so far on on chess. I'm pretty sure they did some done some I'm pretty sure they did some done some I'm pretty sure they did some done some yeah, yeah, yeah, in-depth post training on the model and in-depth post training on the model and in-depth post training on the model and you can really see in the reasoning you can really see in the reasoning you can really see in the reasoning traces that it really understands chess traces that it really understands chess traces that it really understands chess a lot better than the previous models. a lot better than the previous models. a lot better than the previous models. But what we have now put on top of that But what we have now put on top of that But what we have now put on top of that particular model is a list of tools. So, particular model is a list of tools. So, particular model is a list of tools. So, what have you got? We've got a tool for what have you got? We've got a tool for what have you got? We've got a tool for legal moves Um, yeah, to just prevent it legal moves Um, yeah, to just prevent it legal moves Um, yeah, to just prevent it from ever like thinking about something from ever like thinking about something from ever like thinking about something completely illegal, right, on a completely illegal, right, on a completely illegal, right, on a chessboard, which might otherwise chessboard, which might otherwise chessboard, which might otherwise happen. Then we basically give the agent happen. Then we basically give the agent happen. Then we basically give the agent a complete chessboard and let it play a complete chessboard and let it play a complete chessboard and let it play moves and take them back and go to moves and take them back and go to moves and take them back and go to various variations itself. various variations itself. various variations itself. It can then always run a chess engine It can then always run a chess engine It can then always run a chess engine and yeah, also have get some other kind and yeah, also have get some other kind and yeah, also have get some other kind of chess data, for example, looking at of chess data, for example, looking at of chess data, for example, looking at checks, captures and threats. And yeah, checks, captures and threats. And yeah, checks, captures and threats. And yeah, for some kind of videos we also include for some kind of videos we also include for some kind of videos we also include web search because then might be web search because then might be web search because then might be interesting to also describe the interesting to also describe the interesting to also describe the historic context of a game or something historic context of a game or something historic context of a game or something like that. like that. like that. So, looking at one particular tool in in So, looking at one particular tool in in So, looking at one particular tool in in detail, there's the checks, captures and detail, there's the checks, captures and detail, there's the checks, captures and threats tool. Um, that's actually quite threats tool. Um, that's actually quite threats tool. Um, that's actually quite well known in chess as a like a like a well known in chess as a like a like a well known in chess as a like a like a beginner's explanation of what you beginner's explanation of what you beginner's explanation of what you should be focusing on if you've got a should be focusing on if you've got a should be focusing on if you've got a position. So, this is a relatively position. So, this is a relatively position. So, this is a relatively complicated position in which I'm I'm complicated position in which I'm I'm complicated position in which I'm I'm guessing not that many people in the guessing not that many people in the guessing not that many people in the audience would immediately know which audience would immediately know which audience would immediately know which one is the best move. I mean, does Does one is the best move. I mean, does Does one is the best move. I mean, does Does anyone want to have a guess at it? anyone want to have a guess at it? anyone want to have a guess at it? Well, I mean, it's it's pretty Well, I mean, it's it's pretty Well, I mean, it's it's pretty complicated to be honest. It's a tie complicated to be honest. It's a tie complicated to be honest. It's a tie game. game. game. Um, but what we're giving the the LLM Um, but what we're giving the the LLM Um, but what we're giving the the LLM now in this situation is not only the now in this situation is not only the now in this situation is not only the best move, but we're giving it also best move, but we're giving it also best move, but we're giving it also access to checks, captures and threats access to checks, captures and threats access to checks, captures and threats because it otherwise might might miss because it otherwise might might miss because it otherwise might might miss that. And you can see that there are a that. And you can see that there are a that. And you can see that there are a couple of check moves, um, yeah, on the couple of check moves, um, yeah, on the couple of check moves, um, yeah, on the left board. left board. left board. Um, some of which are obviously wrong. Um, some of which are obviously wrong. Um, some of which are obviously wrong. So, like for example, with the queen So, like for example, with the queen So, like for example, with the queen taking the bishop on on A4 is obviously taking the bishop on on A4 is obviously taking the bishop on on A4 is obviously a bad move. Um, some other queen moves a bad move. Um, some other queen moves a bad move. Um, some other queen moves to give a check, they are quite to give a check, they are quite to give a check, they are quite reasonable, but actually the best move reasonable, but actually the best move reasonable, but actually the best move in this whole situation is to sacrifice in this whole situation is to sacrifice in this whole situation is to sacrifice the rook on E3, which is not completely the rook on E3, which is not completely the rook on E3, which is not completely obvious here, but that's actually the obvious here, but that's actually the obvious here, but that's actually the best move. best move. best move. In other situations it might be, In other situations it might be, In other situations it might be, however, much better to look at the however, much better to look at the however, much better to look at the check of the at the capture moves. check of the at the capture moves. check of the at the capture moves. And by providing all this via one tool, And by providing all this via one tool, And by providing all this via one tool, we give quite some diversity to the we give quite some diversity to the we give quite some diversity to the agent to um then maybe maybe later on agent to um then maybe maybe later on agent to um then maybe maybe later on explore other kinds of variations. So, explore other kinds of variations. So, explore other kinds of variations. So, maybe it wants to check all of these maybe it wants to check all of these maybe it wants to check all of these moves and and moves and and moves and and yeah, describe which ones are actually yeah, describe which ones are actually yeah, describe which ones are actually bad because a human might think about bad because a human might think about bad because a human might think about them. And it's so it's not always about them. And it's so it's not always about them. And it's so it's not always about the very very best move which we have to the very very best move which we have to the very very best move which we have to describe. describe. describe. Um Um Um in general in general in general the big question is who should do the the big question is who should do the the big question is who should do the thinking. So, when we started this whole thinking. So, when we started this whole thinking. So, when we started this whole project, we initially had a like a some project, we initially had a like a some project, we initially had a like a some Python scripts which would analyze a Python scripts which would analyze a Python scripts which would analyze a chess position and would then assemble chess position and would then assemble chess position and would then assemble information from various information from various information from various positions and would say, "Okay, here are positions and would say, "Okay, here are positions and would say, "Okay, here are the the check moves and that's the the the check moves and that's the the the check moves and that's the engine evaluation." And then we would engine evaluation." And then we would engine evaluation." And then we would then pass it on to the then pass it on to the then pass it on to the language model to then have a whole language model to then have a whole language model to then have a whole description. But, what um description. But, what um description. But, what um changed last year when reasoning models changed last year when reasoning models changed last year when reasoning models came out came out came out was actually that the the agents could was actually that the the agents could was actually that the the agents could um um um yeah, yeah, rather think themselves about the the rather think themselves about the the rather think themselves about the the positions. And they were already pretty positions. And they were already pretty positions. And they were already pretty good. So, good. So, good. So, the best model which we've been using the best model which we've been using the best model which we've been using like in in autumn last year was Grok 4. like in in autumn last year was Grok 4. like in in autumn last year was Grok 4. Surprisingly, that was sort of the best Surprisingly, that was sort of the best Surprisingly, that was sort of the best one. But, um yeah, also the other models one. But, um yeah, also the other models one. But, um yeah, also the other models like from OpenAI and so on, they also like from OpenAI and so on, they also like from OpenAI and so on, they also have quite some decent base chess have quite some decent base chess have quite some decent base chess knowledge to be able to then call the knowledge to be able to then call the knowledge to be able to then call the tools at the right position and then tools at the right position and then tools at the right position and then like assemble all the knowledge. like assemble all the knowledge. like assemble all the knowledge. And yeah, as I already mentioned, this And yeah, as I already mentioned, this And yeah, as I already mentioned, this kind of conflicting information which we kind of conflicting information which we kind of conflicting information which we provide by the tools is actually very provide by the tools is actually very provide by the tools is actually very beneficial. So, um we also have other beneficial. So, um we also have other beneficial. So, um we also have other kind of tools which more more geared kind of tools which more more geared kind of tools which more more geared towards towards towards um yeah, having um yeah, having um yeah, having getting out the more human moves and getting out the more human moves and getting out the more human moves and positions. And yeah, that also helps to positions. And yeah, that also helps to positions. And yeah, that also helps to balance the the description of not being balance the the description of not being balance the the description of not being too much focused on the best moves, but too much focused on the best moves, but too much focused on the best moves, but also like on the most human moves. Also, also like on the most human moves. Also, also like on the most human moves. Also, in the historical context, there might in the historical context, there might in the historical context, there might be like some valuable information be like some valuable information be like some valuable information which moves have actually been played or which moves have actually been played or which moves have actually been played or someone might have described something someone might have described something someone might have described something in in detail which we might want to in in detail which we might want to in in detail which we might want to analyze. analyze. analyze. So, all these kind of things um get into So, all these kind of things um get into So, all these kind of things um get into the mix in the context. the mix in the context. the mix in the context. Yeah, after we did the whole analysis, Yeah, after we did the whole analysis, Yeah, after we did the whole analysis, we would then create it into a special we would then create it into a special we would then create it into a special format which we could then easily format which we could then easily format which we could then easily transfer into a um transfer into a um transfer into a um yeah, into a video. Um we then use 11 yeah, into a video. Um we then use 11 yeah, into a video. Um we then use 11 Labs V3 for text-to-speech. Yeah, it's Labs V3 for text-to-speech. Yeah, it's Labs V3 for text-to-speech. Yeah, it's actually pretty nice that there are now actually pretty nice that there are now actually pretty nice that there are now also these audio tags like I can put also these audio tags like I can put also these audio tags like I can put this excited in there and it would then this excited in there and it would then this excited in there and it would then sound excited. sound excited. sound excited. And yeah, and also the agent also And yeah, and also the agent also And yeah, and also the agent also decides by itself which squares it wants decides by itself which squares it wants decides by itself which squares it wants to highlight, which arrows want it wants to highlight, which arrows want it wants to highlight, which arrows want it wants to draw, and if something should be to draw, and if something should be to draw, and if something should be considered a brilliant move or not. Yeah, and now maybe also some other Yeah, and now maybe also some other questions. So, is that all slop which we questions. So, is that all slop which we questions. So, is that all slop which we are which we are creating? are which we are creating? are which we are creating? I think not, obviously. I think not, obviously. I think not, obviously. Um Um but yeah, I mean we are able to create but yeah, I mean we are able to create but yeah, I mean we are able to create many many many such videos. So, we have many many many such videos. So, we have many many many such videos. So, we have to really balance of how much do we want to really balance of how much do we want to really balance of how much do we want to put out there on YouTube. So, um what to put out there on YouTube. So, um what to put out there on YouTube. So, um what is the input? I mean, the input is is the input? I mean, the input is is the input? I mean, the input is actually human games. So, in a in a actually human games. So, in a in a actually human games. So, in a in a sense um sense um sense um what we are now positioned at is we what we are now positioned at is we what we are now positioned at is we could be creating videos of your games could be creating videos of your games could be creating videos of your games and you could send the videos then to and you could send the videos then to and you could send the videos then to your friends and family. your friends and family. your friends and family. And um And um And um we are not trying to um I don't know, we are not trying to um I don't know, we are not trying to um I don't know, put in these artificial things like put in these artificial things like put in these artificial things like exploding position um like uh exploding exploding position um like uh exploding exploding position um like uh exploding kings or something like that on check kings or something like that on check kings or something like that on check checkmate which might might be checkmate which might might be checkmate which might might be beneficial for the view count and so on, beneficial for the view count and so on, beneficial for the view count and so on, but we are really trying to yeah, get but we are really trying to yeah, get but we are really trying to yeah, get the most out of the chess quality. the most out of the chess quality. the most out of the chess quality. Uh in general, why are we doing this? I Uh in general, why are we doing this? I Uh in general, why are we doing this? I mean, there are a lot of interesting and mean, there are a lot of interesting and mean, there are a lot of interesting and great streamers. So, for example, Gotham great streamers. So, for example, Gotham great streamers. So, for example, Gotham Chess is one one maybe the the uh the Chess is one one maybe the the uh the Chess is one one maybe the the uh the most well-known streamer. most well-known streamer. most well-known streamer. But they he would probably not um But they he would probably not um But they he would probably not um describe one of your games or my games describe one of your games or my games describe one of your games or my games uh in his videos. But we now have a a uh in his videos. But we now have a a uh in his videos. But we now have a a way to also scale for other people who way to also scale for other people who way to also scale for other people who are not like the best players in the are not like the best players in the are not like the best players in the world and who might which world and who might which world and who might which Yeah, might also like to have a video. Yeah, might also like to have a video. Yeah, might also like to have a video. And yeah, we've got a YouTube channel And yeah, we've got a YouTube channel And yeah, we've got a YouTube channel and um yeah, currently it's like and um yeah, currently it's like and um yeah, currently it's like something like 500k views. something like 500k views. something like 500k views. And yeah, more than 4,000 subscribers. And yeah, more than 4,000 subscribers. And yeah, more than 4,000 subscribers. Most of them actually were um yeah, Most of them actually were um yeah, Most of them actually were um yeah, subscribed within the last month. So, subscribed within the last month. So, subscribed within the last month. So, it's actually going up quite a bit it's actually going up quite a bit it's actually going up quite a bit there. there. there. Yeah, and that's it. If you've got any Yeah, and that's it. If you've got any Yeah, and that's it. If you've got any more questions, I mean, ask them or send more questions, I mean, ask them or send more questions, I mean, ask them or send me a message via these platforms here, me a message via these platforms here, me a message via these platforms here, whatever, and yeah, that's it. Yeah. Yeah. Uh how how Uh how how Uh how how what are the what are the costs? Are you what are the what are the costs? Are you what are the what are the costs? Are you monetizing the YouTube channel to like monetizing the YouTube channel to like monetizing the YouTube channel to like covering the element of the costs? covering the element of the costs? covering the element of the costs? Yeah. Yeah. Well, currently we don't make any money Well, currently we don't make any money Well, currently we don't make any money yet because we're not haven't reached yet because we're not haven't reached yet because we're not haven't reached the monetization stage yet. And so, it's the monetization stage yet. And so, it's the monetization stage yet. And so, it's net minus at the moment. But, okay, net minus at the moment. But, okay, net minus at the moment. But, okay, might change. We'll see. So, you use self-modifying media with So, you use self-modifying media with like how many videos you generating and like how many videos you generating and like how many videos you generating and how many like how many like how many like if the quality better if the quality better if the quality better Yeah, I mean, so um this whole Yeah, I mean, so um this whole Yeah, I mean, so um this whole uh automation we only like enabled like uh automation we only like enabled like uh automation we only like enabled like a couple of weeks ago. And so, currently a couple of weeks ago. And so, currently a couple of weeks ago. And so, currently I'm still like a little bit skeptic. I'm still like a little bit skeptic. I'm still like a little bit skeptic. Should I really like just leave it uh Should I really like just leave it uh Should I really like just leave it uh upload videos? And yeah, I'm mostly upload videos? And yeah, I'm mostly upload videos? And yeah, I'm mostly still leaning on okay, I still want to still leaning on okay, I still want to still leaning on okay, I still want to watch them first once. watch them first once. watch them first once. But, um yeah, the error rate is actually But, um yeah, the error rate is actually But, um yeah, the error rate is actually pretty low. So, I would say every 20th pretty low. So, I would say every 20th pretty low. So, I would say every 20th um video maybe has a a very weird um video maybe has a a very weird um video maybe has a a very weird description in which there's I don't description in which there's I don't description in which there's I don't know, know, know, a checkmate uh and uh that's missed or a checkmate uh and uh that's missed or a checkmate uh and uh that's missed or something like that. But, I mean, that's something like that. But, I mean, that's something like that. But, I mean, that's usually also then of uh valuable usually also then of uh valuable usually also then of uh valuable information, right? Because maybe some information, right? Because maybe some information, right? Because maybe some like one tool call was not done at the like one tool call was not done at the like one tool call was not done at the very end and okay, we can learn very end and okay, we can learn very end and okay, we can learn something from that. But, I've actually something from that. But, I've actually something from that. But, I've actually much more now switched to okay, I don't much more now switched to okay, I don't much more now switched to okay, I don't care anymore. And even if there's a bad care anymore. And even if there's a bad care anymore. And even if there's a bad a then I'll take it down afterwards, a then I'll take it down afterwards, a then I'll take it down afterwards, maybe. Yeah. Yeah. Anything else? Anything else? Yeah. What is the average cost per Yeah. What is the average cost per Yeah. What is the average cost per video? video? video? Um it's um something on the order of, Um it's um something on the order of, Um it's um something on the order of, yeah, 20-30 cents, something like that. yeah, 20-30 cents, something like that. yeah, 20-30 cents, something like that. So, I mean, we also have created a So, I mean, we also have created a So, I mean, we also have created a couple of other videos which are like uh couple of other videos which are like uh couple of other videos which are like uh much much longer, and there it can also much much longer, and there it can also much much longer, and there it can also get to euros and something like that. Um get to euros and something like that. Um get to euros and something like that. Um currently, we are not trying to optimize currently, we are not trying to optimize currently, we are not trying to optimize the costs too much because um the costs too much because um the costs too much because um uh we rather want to error error on uh we rather want to error error on uh we rather want to error error on having it too good description, sort of. having it too good description, sort of. having it too good description, sort of. And but there are also a couple of And but there are also a couple of And but there are also a couple of optimization possibilities in there. I optimization possibilities in there. I optimization possibilities in there. I don't know, redundant tool calls. don't know, redundant tool calls. don't know, redundant tool calls. Sometimes the agent goes through a game Sometimes the agent goes through a game Sometimes the agent goes through a game like twice or something like that, and like twice or something like that, and like twice or something like that, and yeah, that's obviously stupid in a yeah, that's obviously stupid in a yeah, that's obviously stupid in a sense. Yeah. You were talking about Yeah. You were talking about human move. Is it like computer master human move. Is it like computer master human move. Is it like computer master human move or like the human move? human move or like the human move? human move or like the human move? You might put in the mix. Yeah, You might put in the mix. Yeah, You might put in the mix. Yeah, basically all. I mean, so there's this basically all. I mean, so there's this basically all. I mean, so there's this this um this um this um uh Maya engine which was also mentioned uh Maya engine which was also mentioned uh Maya engine which was also mentioned uh yesterday in the talk, so um by the uh yesterday in the talk, so um by the uh yesterday in the talk, so um by the University of Toronto, which um yeah, University of Toronto, which um yeah, University of Toronto, which um yeah, they trained a model in which you can they trained a model in which you can they trained a model in which you can basically uh put a yeah, rating of uh of basically uh put a yeah, rating of uh of basically uh put a yeah, rating of uh of a player, and then it would roughly um a player, and then it would roughly um a player, and then it would roughly um give you a move which that player might give you a move which that player might give you a move which that player might want to play. But it's not like it I want to play. But it's not like it I want to play. But it's not like it I mean, it's not like perfect sense, mean, it's not like perfect sense, mean, it's not like perfect sense, right? But it still might be valuable right? But it still might be valuable right? But it still might be valuable information that maybe some move like information that maybe some move like information that maybe some move like this uh deserves a description. So, we this uh deserves a description. So, we this uh deserves a description. So, we don't necessarily need to have what don't necessarily need to have what don't necessarily need to have what really a human would be playing of that really a human would be playing of that really a human would be playing of that strength, but rather like a mix of strength, but rather like a mix of strength, but rather like a mix of different things to consider. different things to consider. different things to consider. So, for example, like a 1,000 rating So, for example, like a 1,000 rating So, for example, like a 1,000 rating Yes, exactly. Yes, exactly. Yes, exactly. >> 1,600 elo or you know, something. Yeah. You want to explain to you. Yeah. You want to explain to you. Yes, I mean, these these things could Yes, I mean, these these things could Yes, I mean, these these things could also be used then for targeting a little also be used then for targeting a little also be used then for targeting a little bit more like for the audience rather bit more like for the audience rather bit more like for the audience rather have like videos for better players or have like videos for better players or have like videos for better players or videos for worse players. And um in videos for worse players. And um in videos for worse players. And um in currently currently currently uh we are also not really sure exactly uh we are also not really sure exactly uh we are also not really sure exactly how which videos we should be putting up how which videos we should be putting up how which videos we should be putting up there or not. I mean, sometimes we also there or not. I mean, sometimes we also there or not. I mean, sometimes we also have videos with a checkmate in one, have videos with a checkmate in one, have videos with a checkmate in one, which for like good players is sort of which for like good players is sort of which for like good players is sort of ridiculous. I mean, you see it ridiculous. I mean, you see it ridiculous. I mean, you see it immediately. But on the other hand, immediately. But on the other hand, immediately. But on the other hand, there there there there there there real beginners who really don't see that real beginners who really don't see that real beginners who really don't see that and need also an explanation uh why and need also an explanation uh why and need also an explanation uh why that's a checkmate and so on. So, yeah, that's a checkmate and so on. So, yeah, that's a checkmate and so on. So, yeah, it's it's all a bit of a balancing it's it's all a bit of a balancing it's it's all a bit of a balancing question, which we are not really sure question, which we are not really sure question, which we are not really sure yet. yet. yet. Yeah. Have you tried other games? Yeah. Have you tried other games? Yeah. Have you tried other games? No, not yet. No, not yet. No, not yet. But yeah, I mean, it's sort of uh But yeah, I mean, it's sort of uh But yeah, I mean, it's sort of uh possible to extend in some, yeah.